i was referring to how i would spend my money not how i would take it apart.
mazak ball screws are top shelf, in my experience lost motion is generally in the thrust bearings, i have had 1 screw go bad on a QT8 but have replaced many thrust bearings.
now, if i had the motor uncoupled and the screw felt like a bag of rocks thats when i would look at replace or repair of the ball screw.
I'm not arguing or disapproving of your work, you got your machine up and running and saved a bunch of money over giving someone a blank check to do the work, I'm just stating what i have run across in 25+ years of doing this for the next guy that does a search on ball screw, leaving that screw in and just replacing the bearing on the ends of the screw could save alot of time and money.
|