Results 1 to 16 of 16
09-06-2011, 05:56 PM #1
How to idenitfy original 10EE chucks
I am trying to get back to my 10 EE project and am looking for a couple of chuck’s . I don’t have the funds right now for new ones so I have been looking around for suitable used ones. Unless I get lucky and find them at a auction I think e-bay will be my only source. After looking through the past posts it seems that the original 10EE chucks were a 6" Cushman 3-jaw and 8" Skinner 4-jaw are forged steel and lightened. Is that correct?
So my question is how would I identify the correct chucks on ebay? Is there a part # or some other way to identify the correct chucks? My main concern is getting a chuck that is rated for the speed of the Monarch.
09-06-2011, 07:48 PM #2
One fairly easy way to confirm OE type chucks are; the direct mount, none of the 3 or 4 jaw chucks originally supplied had back plates. The four jaws would all have lightning holes, I think. I do have a 8" 4 jaw with a direct mount that is not lightened, it did not come with my lathe. I can also say that the 6" 4 jaw Cushman's came in two styles, my lathe had the light jaw version with it and I picked up a heavy jaw a while back. I have not seen one on ebay for a while but there were also Cushman 6 jaw direct mount chucks.
09-06-2011, 08:28 PM #3
Many, if not all, 10EE chucks (and other tooling like face plates and steady rests) were stamped with the machine's serial number. If you find something like EE12345 or EE-7890 stamped on the mounting side of the chuck, it was most likely sold with a 10EE.
09-06-2011, 11:29 PM #4
"... it seems that the original 10EE chucks were a 6" Cushman 3-jaw and 8" Skinner 4-jaw are forged steel and lightened. Is that correct?"
The standard chucks were a 6" Cushman forged steel 3-jaw scroll chuck with two sets of jaws and an 8" Skinner forged steel 4-jaw independent chuck with the back lightened during casting and the void painted.
These are direct mount with no back.
If the chuck(s) was (were) supplied with a new machine, then the chuck(s) would be stamped with the machine's serial number.
The same is true of the dog drive plate and the faceplate, both of which are made of cast iron, NOT steel, and are not intended for operation at maximum speed.
It seems that most eBay 10EE accessories were stripped from an otherwise intact machine, at some point in time, as these usually have an EE+S/N stamped on them, too.
These numbers are in addition to the four digit "EE number" which is a casting pattern number.
The Hardinge-Sjogren Speed-Chuck was also especially made for the 10EE, and is a model 2A-D3", not the standard 2-D3". The "A" indicates a smaller handwheel and a higher maximum rated speed of 4,000 rpm. These are also direct mount.
09-07-2011, 11:18 AM #5
What is the diameter of the Handwheel on the "2A-D3" Sojgren, if you happen to have easy access to that?
09-07-2011, 03:02 PM #6
"What is the diameter of the Handwheel on the "2A-D3" Sojgren, if you happen to have easy access to that?"
I believe the standard handwheel is 10", the special handwheel for the 10EE is 9".
The internal components of the two are not interchangable, so the 2A-D3" is a completely new model.
09-07-2011, 03:51 PM #7
After reading this thread I checked the chucks that I got with me '42 10EE.
The 6-jaw is missing the round label, has no serial#'s stamped, and has a backing plate. That said, it does look like the other Cushman's I've seen.
The 4-jaw has a Cushman tag and has a 5-digit number stamped on the mount side, but no EE designation. The stamped number is not the same as the lathe serial. It has no backing plate and is lightened.
09-07-2011, 07:03 PM #8
"The 4-jaw has a Cushman tag and has a 5-digit number stamped on the mount side, but no EE designation. The stamped number is not the same as the lathe serial. It has no backing plate and is lightened."
Some chucks have EEnnnnn stamped on them, others don't.
Rowe Machinery in Santa Cruz has several sets of inside jaws, should yours be missing them. Most are.
The jaws have a unique sequence number and a jaw number stamped into the web.
The last time I was there (Rowe's), I sorted through all the Cushman 3-jaw jaws and placed them together in sets.
Its probably a good idea to have two such Cushmans, one with outside jaws and the other with inside jaws mounted.
09-07-2011, 09:04 PM #9
I have all of the original tooling that came with my 10EE - but I'll never use it as it's 50+ years old and beat to hell. The newer Buck and Bison chucks have better jaws, center better and just plain work better. So if you're looking to get similar tooling as came with the 10EE: go for it! A lightweight 8" 4 jaw, a 6" 3 jaw a faceplate and a dog driving plate and you're in business.
Just don't become a tooling whore like me. I don't need the competition with Daryl already out there.
09-07-2011, 11:05 PM #10
09-07-2011, 11:47 PM #11
I got a Monarch faceplate and dog driver off of ebay form some guy in New Mexico. I think he got a load of tooling out of the Los Alamos lab. The faceplate looks like new.
I dont really care too much about being all original. I would prefer a direct D3 mount like original and one that can handle the10EE speed. If i was buying new. I like the SCA chucks but they are pricey. I dont think SCA makes a direct mount steel 6" chuck any more. I went to the SCA site and they have Bergmans direct mount. I have a feeling that the Bergmans are made in China?
It will be a while before i get the lathe running so i have time to look around.
Thanks a bunch for the help everyone.
09-08-2011, 10:25 AM #12
I really don't like working on a manual lathe with a part doing 4K, too much energy in the system for me to be comfortable standing new it. Must be getting chicken in my old age.
09-08-2011, 12:57 PM #13
09-08-2011, 02:39 PM #14
09-08-2011, 04:34 PM #15
Yessir! thats the baby. I can imagine I would use the crap outa that! I have a D-3 nose mount project to do, but since the move haven't been setup for it.
09-08-2011, 04:36 PM #16