As always, thank you for the help and knowledge. I have some follow up questions for you.
- While poking through eBay listings, I'm seeing mH ratings all over the map. So long as we hit the current rating do we care what the inductance ratings is? If we do what range should we be shooting for?
As stated:
- 20 MICRO Henry will knock the spikes off, motor survives the remaining insult of pulses. It also "growls", especially on hard accel or decel.
- 20 MILLI Henry will significantly aid the motor- which OTHERWISE must "integrate" the pulses in the current realm, not Voltage - all by itself.
LATER technology "RPM" motors were re-designed to do that better. Our older motors are NOT good at it. And even the "RPM" family want ripple-filters.
Now the "growl" is distributed, more of it obvious at the choke than at the motor, but the overall system is VERY much smoother, and can run at lower RPM smoothly, too.
"In between is .. would you believe it? "In between!"
NB:
A) UNLIKE a Variable FREQUENCY Drive for AC, DC Drives of the "thyristor" class operate at the same "line derived" frequency all the time, and for all loads. They "control" by altering the 'ON-TIME" or "Duty Cycle" of each pulse, not the frequency. LIGHT loads have very short "ON" time, very loooong "OFF" time, and are noisier than HEAVY loading.
FWIW-not-much, "PWM" DC drives are closer cousins to VFD with the output rectified. Not well-suited, here.
SCR drives have:
- 120 Hz or "two pulse" for MOST 60 Hz incoming single-phase,
- 360 Hz or "six pulse" for MOST 60 Hz incoming 3-Phase.
Wherein SOME high-end SCR DC Drives apply a ration of (patented) "pseudo-phasing" kinky-f**kery to multiply that to 12 or even 24 pulses.
Take note as you eyeball the PCB that:
- a "1Q" drive such as the Beel/BICL D510 has but ONE trigger inductor. It is "contactor reversed", only has two controlled rectifiers in its packaged matrix. The other two freewheel. Rough as a cob. over 120 V "AC Component" measured.
- a "2Q" Sprint DC Drive on
3-Phase has SIX rectifiers under active control. Two per phase, one each direction.
- a "4Q" SSD 514C SINGLE phase drive doesn't have just two. It has EIGHT trigger inductors for a 12 Diode matrix!
Smoother drive than average. Even before the choke is added.
[*]I'm seeing a lot of "line reactors" on eBay made for 3 phase. With three separate coils, could one coil be used for the Armature + and another used for the Field + to smooth them both with the same unit? If so and we use a choke rated for 20A does that way over-sized choke still work well on the Field side only drawing 1.5A?
[/LIST]
Cheap as they are I have 3 or 4 of those around, various Amperage ratings, Emerson/TCI "Sine Guard" models.
I use them ON 3-Phase .. for "armouring" my overly-electronificated residence against nastiness off the Phase-Perfect .. and more.
They can "help", used as postulated.
They are FAR from optimal.
You want a "DC choke".
10EE Field is a skosh under 2 Amps, yes.
DO keep in mind it is now serving load-motor Field ONLY.
There is no longer any DC panel with contactor actuating coils, nor Braking/Acell, Braking, nor even Field Loss relay to power.
I use Lenze conventionals ELSE smaller Coilcraft ferrite core chokes for the SSD 50X Field supply.
I have..3 if not 4? "Field REGULATOR" boxes here to play with as well....when I get a round-tuit. Caratron, Siemens, etc....
"To Be Determined" whether I filter those or not, but "probably".
B) All this shite happens in the AUDIO frequency spectrum.
One can sidestep the cost of a four-trace Rigol 'scope and the far HIGHER cost of good US made high-voltage probes - also avoid risky exposure to high voltage outright..and still learn a LOT by....
Sticking some cheap "contact" microphones on motor, ripple-filter, toolpost..
and then .. monitoring the sound spectrum in any garden-variety audio spectrum analyzer software on a call phone or laptop.
Most already have it for free - because so many folk are "into" music..
I also own a Sound Pressure Level meter.
Given I'm kinda
DEAF!
Not old age, either! Mum had phenomenal hearing past 90 years of age.
101st Airborne, "rear" Div Arty, 175 mm gun "fire mission".
Forgiven, lo more than half a century.
Valiant cannon-cockers HARD NAILED the NVA. One round of pee-bringer!
That makes it worth it!
