1. Stainless
Join Date
Jul 2006
Location
rochester, ny
Posts
1,927
Post Thanks / Like
Likes (Given)
391
540

The flatness spec for some Blanchard ground plate is .002"/ft. So for a 4' long piece, does that mean .008" over the 4' length?

I ask because if you calculate the radius of a 12" long .002" deep arc, and then draw a 4' long arc of that radius, the total curvature is much greater than .008"

2. Diamond
Join Date
Mar 2005
Location
Northwest Indiana
Posts
4,216
Post Thanks / Like
Likes (Given)
845
847
You'd probably better get that clarified by the grind shop quoting the job. Most likely it means a plate ground on both sides will measure within .002"/foot of parallel. Not very inspiring accuracy BTW.

3. Stainless
Join Date
Jan 2013
Location
Plainfield, Indiana, USA
Posts
1,745
Post Thanks / Like
Likes (Given)
1328
928
The radius has nothing to do with flatness. The spec means just what it says, nothing about radii. The best you can do is measure over a 4' length and expect </= 0.008" total deviation.

4. Diamond
Join Date
Jun 2012
Country
UNITED STATES
State/Province
Michigan
Posts
10,185
Post Thanks / Like
Likes (Given)
3456
3639
Don't know about that but we Blanchard ground a 36" chuck full of inserts, TCT and blades to +- .001" and better

5. Diamond
Join Date
Dec 2008
Country
UNITED STATES
State/Province
New York
Posts
10,215
Post Thanks / Like
Likes (Given)
0
2653
Originally Posted by richard newman
The flatness spec for some Blanchard ground plate is .002"/ft. So for a 4' long piece, does that mean .008" over the 4' length?

I ask because if you calculate the radius of a 12" long .002" deep arc, and then draw a 4' long arc of that radius, the total curvature is much greater than .008"
.
often there is 2 tolerances the .002" per foot is a wavy tolerance and if any parallel passes the lap or height difference between the passes. then there might be an overall flatness tolerance across the whole part surface which could be much higher.
.
typically you might have a .0005" TIR wavy or lap tolerance per foot (like when checking with indicator going across the surface it might be going +/-.00015 or .0003" TIR) and a .0010" tolerance across the whole part surface.
.
wavy or lap error often from spindle tram error (leaning slightly), tool wear, or just localized hard spots that resisted cutting/grinding more than other spots. if you blue up surface and hand stone or lap it you will often see shiny high spots often of only .0002"

6. Flatness simply describes two planes between which the entire surface must lie.

So in any one foot section, the entire surface of the part must be within .002" of every other portion of the surface within that foot.

The second foot has no relation to the first foot.

The bar could be bent 90° at the intersection of the 1st foot and the 2nd foot, and still pass flatness spec.

7. Titanium
Join Date
Sep 2005
Location
Oakland, CA
Posts
2,495
Post Thanks / Like
Likes (Given)
298
672
If Teach Me had stopped after the 2nd sentence above he would have been 100% correct.

8. Diamond
Join Date
Oct 2010
Country
UNITED STATES
State/Province
Oregon
Posts
5,110
Post Thanks / Like
Likes (Given)
4392
1854
The bar could be bent 90° at the intersection of the 1st foot and the 2nd foot, and still pass flatness spec.
But crucially, no foot that includes the bend would pass.

9. Diamond
Join Date
Mar 2005
Location
Northwest Indiana
Posts
4,216
Post Thanks / Like
Likes (Given)
845
847
It would not pass flatness. It would pass parallelism.

10. Diamond
Join Date
Feb 2004
Location
peekskill, NY
Posts
24,447
Post Thanks / Like
Likes (Given)
0
4563
Flatness simply describes two planes between which the entire surface must lie.
So in any one foot section, the entire surface of the part must be within .002" of every other portion of the surface within that foot.
The second foot has no relation to the first foot.
The bar could be bent 90° at the intersection of the 1st foot and the 2nd foot, and still pass flatness spec.
+1

Flatness discusses *one* surface only. By its nature it cannot say anything about parallelism of two surfaces.

11. Diamond
Join Date
Mar 2005
Location
Northwest Indiana
Posts
4,216
Post Thanks / Like
Likes (Given)
845
847
Nobody said that it did, nor argued otherwise! The only claim made was that a plate bent to 90° could potentially pass a parallelism spec of .002" but NOT a flatness spec of .002".

12. Diamond
Join Date
Feb 2004
Location
peekskill, NY
Posts
24,447
Post Thanks / Like
Likes (Given)
0
4563
Originally Posted by eKretz
Nobody said that it did, nor argued otherwise! The only claim made was that a plate bent to 90° could potentially pass a parallelism spec of .002" but NOT a flatness spec of .002".
Could NOT pass a parallelism spec because the underside the plate is all wavy. But if the spec it written such that the one test area is in one
section for a foot, and another section for the second foot, then it would pass. Make the test 0.002 flatness over the entire piece, then no
it would indeed fail.

13. Originally Posted by richard newman
The flatness spec for some Blanchard ground plate is .002"/ft. So for a 4' long piece, does that mean .008" over the 4' length?

I ask because if you calculate the radius of a 12" long .002" deep arc, and then draw a 4' long arc of that radius, the total curvature is much greater than .008"
It could, but it would be unusual. If you need better, call it out and be prepared to pay for it.

It sounds like you are assuming the error in flatness will be of uniform geometry. That is far from the result you will receive. You haven't told us the thickness of the plate you are getting ground. For a Blanchard, it matters. A Blanchard has a powerful magnet, it could probably pull 1/32 of bow out of a 2' x 4' plate 2" thick. The end result depends a lot on the flatness of the original stock for thin parts.

Assuming a good machine and a good operator, your part will be flat to better than .001 overall while still on the machine. The result on a surface plate will depend a great deal on the skill of the operator, as well as the requested tolerance. Your plate should be able to be within .002 overall, but you will be paying for a lot of extra machine time for shimming, testing, and flipping.

14. I don't run machines like that but I work on them and watch others run them a lot. Anything but a completely killed piece, meaning multiple heat and chill cycles, is going to warp. They usually rough them down on a Camut grinder, think of one with a Blanchard stone but a linear table like most surface grinders. It has no Y travel because the stone is as big as the table is wide. Then they turn the magnet off and slide shims under the areas that have bowed up. They grind both sides as straight as they can, then move them to a 96" X 48" Mattison, shimming as needed during the process. Next the really picky pieces go on a Chevalier for a final carefully nursed grind. The customer gets a very flat part and pays for it. Those parts are used in a very exacting application and the customer seems to think it is worth it.

Bill

15. Diamond
Join Date
Jan 2007
Location
Flushing/Flint, Michigan
Posts
7,951
Post Thanks / Like
Likes (Given)
400
6584
Originally Posted by michiganbuck
Don't know about that but we Blanchard ground a 36" chuck full of inserts, TCT and blades to +- .001" and better
Good lord I would hope so and hold the batch of 5000 pieces to 1/4 or better of this.
Top and bottom is the first op and you hold it very tight as it will puck with the others that follow.
If you need microns down the line you had sure as shit better have nailed this one or you will be chasing Blanchard loads.
We segregate and mark thickness loads just for this adjustment so that we know when it hits us downstream.
The first op is often so way open but it cascades down the process stream.

Get the first few flat, square, Tir or whatever very tight and all the others that follow are easier.
For sure these features do not need to be way inside print but maybe you do to make life not so complicated.
Bob

16. Stainless
Join Date
Jul 2006
Location
rochester, ny
Posts
1,927
Post Thanks / Like
Likes (Given)
391
540
Originally Posted by gbent
It could, but it would be unusual. If you need better, call it out and be prepared to pay for it.

It sounds like you are assuming the error in flatness will be of uniform geometry. That is far from the result you will receive. You haven't told us the thickness of the plate you are getting ground. For a Blanchard, it matters. A Blanchard has a powerful magnet, it could probably pull 1/32 of bow out of a 2' x 4' plate 2" thick. The end result depends a lot on the flatness of the original stock for thin parts.

Assuming a good machine and a good operator, your part will be flat to better than .001 overall while still on the machine. The result on a surface plate will depend a great deal on the skill of the operator, as well as the requested tolerance. Your plate should be able to be within .002 overall, but you will be paying for a lot of extra machine time for shimming, testing, and flipping.
The spec I quoted was from Nifty Bar for their stock plates 1/2" thru 1-1/2" thick. I think they use hot rolled, not sure if it's stress relieved.
https://niftybar.com/wp-content/uplo...000_1_2017.pdf

I'd gotten a quote for touching up a 1" x 30" x 48" plate that had once been ground, but then welded onto and distorted a bit, and was told could expect flatness of .010" to .015" across the diagonals.

17. Stainless
Join Date
Sep 2008
Country
UNITED STATES
State/Province
California
Posts
1,706
Post Thanks / Like
Likes (Given)
1138
985
Originally Posted by richard newman
The spec I quoted was from Nifty Bar for their stock plates 1/2" thru 1-1/2" thick. I think they use hot rolled, not sure if it's stress relieved.
My local Blanchard grinder really hates cold rolled bar to the extent he'll send it out for stress relieving before grinding. If it goes out with other plates then he'll do it for free.

He much prefers hot rolled plate to start with. Then so do I, cos it's cheaper.

18. Diamond
Join Date
Feb 2004
Location
peekskill, NY
Posts
24,447
Post Thanks / Like
Likes (Given)
0
4563
We were sourcing silicon plates years ago, the tops had to be flat within a micron over the entire surface. These were about 6 inch by
3 inch rectangles, about 3/8 thick.

There was a company called Bond Optics that did these for us. They were checked at our end with a special tool called a Zygo interfermometer.
Basically gave you a fringe pattern over the entire surface. HeNe laser red fringes, about 600 nm, or .6 micron. They made these within
a fringe or two on the top surface. I was impressed.

Bond Optics would build ring laser gyros, all from one solid piece of sapphire. Metalized mirrors and all.

And they're still in business apparently:

Bond Optics | Home

19. Originally Posted by triumph406
My local Blanchard grinder really hates cold rolled bar to the extent he'll send it out for stress relieving before grinding. If it goes out with other plates then he'll do it for free.

He much prefers hot rolled plate to start with. Then so do I, cos it's cheaper.
A friend wanted a rectangular bar that was an improved fit in the table slots of his Craftsman table saw, the kind of job you would decline if it was a walk in stranger. I started with a 3/8" X 5/8" cold rolled bar and wasted almost an entire morning, grinding one side, then flipping it to send the warp back the other way. The damned thing almost rolled up in a ball.

Bill

20. Cast Iron
Join Date
Jan 2007
Location
s w NH
Posts
324
Post Thanks / Like
Likes (Given)
226
119
have seen many jobs spec'd at .00x flatness per foot. some of them quite long, or quite thin. some of these jobs have had the words "in the restrained condition" on the drawing, which means parallelism not flatness is the real issue. many have not, and I have spoken with folk who did the engineering and been told, yes, in the restrained condition is fine. taking the time to make the call has gained me the opportunity to make many of these parts. if I had not made those calls id have had to no quote. and yes, I have had to make calls to get the customer to have his qc dept talk to engineering.