Tanner's system is OK to learn on and it is cheap.
However, it is not strudy enough for heavy use nor large enough for the wide variety of barrels I chamber.
My unit will take up to a 1.350" diameter barrel, has adapters for piping through the headstock when using a steady rest, is quick to install and does not leak. Plus it will not marr the barrel finish.
I use a separate 10 gallon sump with a special mix of high quality water soluble oil with chlorinated extreme pressure additives. The standard mix ratio is 1 part soluble oil to 20 parts water, but I use 1 part soluble oil to 1 part water. Some folks use special witch's brews for their muzzle flush systems. Tanner sells a brew if you want something different. Some of the brews have too much chlorinated additives and you have to wear a respirator when chambering!!! Hovever, a heavy mix of high quality oil as I use works fine. I have heard of using Dextron II and MolyDee mix, but have not tried it yet. Maybe next time I drain & flush the sump.
You need a sump with a centrifugal pump so you can throttle the discharge, to adjust the flow through the barrel so you will not paint the shop with coolant. And I have a pump switch mounted just above the lathe, on a shelf, so I can turn the pump off when withdrawing the reamer. The $100 sump with pump that Enco sells is ideal. Holds 10 gallons.
The muzzle flush system flushes out the chips, keeps the reamer cool, provides a better finish, and allows fast chambering. If you are into chambering barrels as a business as I am, you cannot aford to not use a muzzle flush.
There are a few tricks to learn, like:
How to back out the reamer a little, without shutting the pump off, to clear chips.
How to modify the reamer bushing screw to allow high rate of flow.
Types of reamers to use. Pilot bushing types only, with the screw retainer, and flutes extending fully under the bushing. And you need full sets of bushing for each bore size so you can fit a snug bushing to the bore.
How to start the reamer without work handening the barrel.
How to advance the reamer to avoid work hardening.
And a few other tricks. Most folks go too slow with feeds & speed.
Try it, you will never go back to "wipe and brush". I even have adapters made up for use when chambering loading dies.
[This message has been edited by John Ricks (edited 12-10-2003).]
[This message has been edited by John Ricks (edited 12-10-2003).]